etcd on Digi Hunch

GraphQL and gRPC

Fri, 07 Oct 2022 14:49:00 -0400

Big Picture

For inter-process communication at a high level, the two styles are asynchronous and synchronous styles:

Asynchronous event-driven style: involving an event broker as a middle man.
Synchronous request-response style: including several families of technologies:
- RPC (Remote Procedure Call):
  - CORBA (Common Object Request Broker Architecture)
  - Java RMI (Remote Method Invocation)
- SOAP (Simple Object Access Protocol)
- REST (Representational State Transfer)
- gRPC
- GraphQL
- Apache Thrift

RPCs, built on top of TCP/UDP, are usually complex to implement. SOAP improved it and can operate on HTTP. Many large companies today still used SOAP for message exchange. However, it has a limitation with complex format and specifications for XML messaging, giving rise to REST. REST is not a standard, but rather a loosely defined architectural style. Its payload can be in any format (XML, JSON, etc) specified in the header. As long as the API conforms to certain guidelines (criteria outlined in this article), we can consider the API RESTful. REST has been steadily replacing SOAP in the past few years. In this post, I start with REST, then dive into gRPC and GraphQL.

REST

The de facto method of building microservices using REST architectural style is use HTTP protocol with JSON format payload. JSON format is human readable, but not optimized for machine-to-machine communication. So there is some room for compression. To emulate a web request in REST, one can use curl, a common utility to emulate any HTTP client.

REST has its shortcomings. For example, the interface between REST client and server is not strongly typed. You can choose to use OpenAPI/Swagger specification to define types but it is still not tightly integrated. There is no enforcement on the format of the payload either. RESTful services are quite bulky, inefficient, and error-prone. gRPC and GraphQL emerged to address different challenges with REST. GraphQL operates on HTTP and we can view it as a layer on top of REST in a broad sense. gRPC on the other hand, operates on HTTP /2, and thereby inherits many advantages from it.

HTTP /2

HTTP/2 is the second major version of HTTP. It overcomes some issues with HTTP/1.1 on security, speed, etc. This post is a good rundown of the difference between HTTP /2 and HTTP /1.1, which account for many of the advantages of gRPC. A thorough discussion on the differences between the two HTTP versions is beyond what this post can cover. One of the important difference with HTTP/2, is that all communication between a client and server is performed over a single TCP connection that can carry any number of bidirectional flows of bytes. This makes gRPC a high-performance RPC framework. In HTTP/2, the key concepts to understand are:

Stream: a bidirectional flow of bytes within an established connection. A stream may carry one or more messages;
Frame: the smallest unit of communication in HTTP/2. Each frame contains a frame header, which at a minimum identifies the stream to which the frame belongs.
Message: a complete sequence of frames that map to a logical HTTP message that consists of one or more frames.

The request message is always triggered by the client. During the interaction, the client and server break down the message into frames, interleave them, and then reassemble them on the other side. In this way HTTP /2 multiplex the messages, and enables the following communication patterns:

Simple RPC: a single request and a single response in the communication;
Server Streaming RPC: a single request and message followed by multiple response messages;
Client streaming RPC: client sends multiple messages and the server replies with one response message;
Bi-directional RPC: client setups connection by sending header frames. Once connection is established, both client and server send messages simultaneously without waiting for the other to finish;

The streaming communication patterns fundamentally improves performance, enabling the duplex streaming capability for gRPC.

gRPC

At the protocol level, gRPC has the following advantages over REST:

well-defined service interface and schema
strongly typed data
duplex streaming (thanks to HTTP2)
built-in commodity features (e.g. authentication, encryption, resiliency, service discovery, etc)

I previously touched on gRPC protocol in the context of Envoy and etcd. Envoy makes use of gRPC for its control plane, where it fetches configuration from management server(s) and in filters, such as for rate limiting or authorization checks. Etcd store implements gRPC protocol for client utility to communicate with.

Since the typical use case of gRPC is internal communication, I have not been able to find a playground online. To get a taste of gRPC client-server interaction, just play with etcd on MacOS. gRPC is language neutral. To start developing, refer to the tutorial in different languages (e.g. Golang, Python). When developing a gRPC application, the first thing to do is define a service interface in IDL (interface definition language). gRPC uses protocol buffers as the IDL to define the service interface. Protocol buffers are a language-agnostic, platform-neutral, extensible mechanism to serializing structured data. Using that service interface definition, we can generate the server-side code known as a server skeleton. Also you can generate the client-side code, known as a client stub. The methods that you specify in the service interface definition can be remotely invoked by the client side as easily as making a local function invocation.

gRPC also has some disadvantages. Currently, the ecosystem is still small. When we have a service interface, we have to maintain the interface across versions.

GraphQL

In most of the use cases of gRPC and GraphQL, GraphQL works for external-facing services/APIs while internal services backing the APIs are implemented using gRPC. Honeypot created good documentary for GraphQL available here.

We use GraphQL for external facing services because it gives API client the ability to query. An SQL query allows client to filter requested data based on conditions, and define the interested columns in the data return. This capability is missing in the REST style guideline. One may choose to implement their RESTful service to support their client’s query requirement, GraphQL standardizes this capability with typed data, thereby prevents unnecessary network round trips, over- and under-fetching of data.

The official site is a good reference for learning. One needs to know concepts around queries and mutations, schema and types (scalars, variable, fragment, interfaces, unions) to understand how query works.

This page lists a number of publicly available services in GraphQL. For example, country information service is available here. On the web page you can put in a query like this:

query myCountry {
 countries(filter:{code:{in:"CA"}}) {
 code,
 name,
 capital
 }
}

The query (with the name of myCountry) above asks to return entries with countries as type. Then it filters the result by the condition that the country code must include “CA”. The return should include code, name and capital columns. The web page looks like this:

GraphQL is on HTTP, so I can emulate the call with curl and get the same result:

curl --request POST https://countries.trevorblades.com/ \
--header 'Content-Type: application/json' \
--data-raw '{
 "query" : "query myCountry { countries (filter: { code: { in: \"CA\" } }) {code name capital} }"
}'

The return prints the same result:

The document has a page on library options for different languages, such as Graphene and Ariadne for Python. You can use Ariadne and Flask to build GraphQL API as this post suggests.

The example on this page has a better example that highlights how GraphQL allows client to ask multiple questions at the same time, and how the response includes different pieces of answers. GraphQL backend often needs to connect to different downstream system. This requires a proxy service to connect to disparate data sources. Examples of such services with such capabilities include Apollo, AWS AppSync, or ApiGee.

Summary

For API protocols, we often compare among REST, gRPC and GraphQL. REST is loosely defined and widely adopted for the past few years. The use case of REST diverged into two areas: external facing API and internal service-to-service communication. gRPC and GraphQL are relatively new and they each are good for one of the use cases.

Microservice pattern based on gRPC and GraphQL (source: “gRPC up & running” by Indrasiri & Kuruppu)

The gRPC protocol on HTTP2 is often used in internal communication between microservices. GraphQL offers query capability and is therefore often used to face external client.

Build and Manage Kubernetes Clusters

Fri, 23 Sep 2022 11:50:00 -0400

There are numerous options to build a Kubernetes cluster. If your company has a multi-cloud strategy, most likely you will have to deal with cluster creation on multiple cloud platform or on virtual machines on premise.

Most likely, the chosen cloud platform already make it simple for us. However, it is still important to understand what it really takes to build a Kubernetes cluster. In general, we need to figure out these tasks:

Decide where to host the computing infrastructure (i.e. Node) : on premise or public cloud;
Choose a Kubernetes release: either the vanilla release or one of the third-party distributions;
Install Kubernetes to the computing environment, and integrate it with the cloud platform;
Determine required add-ons (e.g. Istio or Linkerd for Service Mesh, dashboard utility, etc);
Deploy application workload to Kubernetes platform;

A public cloud platform provider usually can assist you with task 1 through 3, and partially 4, depending on the provider. If your Kubernetes resides on private cloud or on-prem environment, you can use a Platform solution such as VMware Tanzu or Openshift, which usually covers task 1, 3 and 4. There is no standard about what task these platform solution must address. Therefore it is important to have this list of tasks in mind in order to make a good comparison. I will discuss each of the tasks in this post.

Hosting environment

Nodes are the building blocks of a Kubernetes cluster. We need master nodes as well as worker nodes. In addition, a working cluster also requires storage, and networking infrastructure.

Public cloud platforms typically provides control plane as a service, obviating administrator’s effort to provision master nodes. For example, the control plane of Azure AKS has two levels of uptime commitment: a free tier of 99.5% SLO and a paid tier with an SLA of 99.95% (using AZs) and 99.9% (without using AZs). This uptime commitment applies to control plane only and do not apply to worker nodes. The management of etcd store is also a responsibility of the cloud provider, which frees up the cluster administrator from managing etcd store. However, they cannot access etcd store either. This is not very convenient because as the size of the cluster grows it is a common requirement to connect to etcd store for troubleshooting purpose.

The deployment APIs for public cloud allow the cluster administrator to define the instance size, count and availability zone for the worker nodes. They also automatically register the worker nodes to control plane so that the cluster administrators do not have to do so by themselves. As to storage, the public cloud usually provide some default storage classes based on their storage as service. For networking device, the cluster provision process automatically configures the cloud API so the cluster can manage cloud resources such as network load balancer.

With private cloud or data centre, we usually use virtual machines, or bare-metal servers. Cluster administrators will need to make their own control plane with master nodes. and install worker nodes and register them to the master nodes. The Kubernetes Installation section below will discuss this.

Kubernetes release

If you have to install Kubernetes, you have to think about the Kubernetes release being used. You can use the binary from official Github repository. For example, the release note of version 1.24.3 points to the change log file for download links to server binaries, node binaries. This is the vanilla Kubernetes release.

Apart from the vanilla release, many developers build their own distributions, based off forks of the Kubernetes project. CNCF has a page to keep track of certified Kubernetes distributions. Some of the distributions are open source and can be used for on-prem infrastructure. Here is a list of top players:

Distribution Name	Repo	Description
EKS Distro	Link	Used in EKS managed service or EKS Anywhere for on-prem infrastructure
AKS Engine	Link	Used in Azure Stack for on-prem infrastructure.
Google Kubernetes Engine	N/A	Used in GKE managed service only.
OpenShift Kubernetes Engine	Link	Community distribution (OKD, or OpenShift Kubernetes Distribution) is the open-source upstream.
Rancher Kubernetes Engine (RKE)	Link	still using Docker as container runtime. Supported CNI include: Canal, Flannel, Calico and Weave
K3s	Link	Lightweight distro without small resource requirement. Great for Edge, IoT, ARM etc
RKE2	Link	Originally named RKE government. Supports deployment via Cluster API. Supports containerd as container runtime. Supported CNI include: Cillium, Calico, Canal and Multus. Lightweight
VMware Tanzu	Link	VMWare Tanzu Grid and VMWare Tanzu Community

Above is just a very incomplete list of Kubernetes distributions. There are many more distributions that are not on this list, such as CoreOS Tectonic, Docker Kubernetes, Heptio, Mesosphere, Mirantis, Platform9, Stackube, Telekube. For full details of how each distribution is different, you will need to go over their documents.

With the selected distribution, we still need to deploy the binaries to the nodes. We can do this with a cluster management platform, or standalone installers. Cluster management platform can also help us with baseline configuration (e.g. IAM integration, CNI plugin), in addition to the binary installation.

Cluster Management Platform

These platforms are also sometimes referred to as container management platform.

For example, OpenShift container platform is a self-managed platform based on OpenShift Kubernetes Engine and can run on a variety of hosting environment, public cloud, or private cloud. The installation steps varies depending on the hosting environment. When running on public cloud such as AWS (aka ROSA), the public cloud only provides computing nodes and associated infrastructure. Many corporate with multi-cluster strategy use this option on public cloud to keep their Kubernetes cluster fleet consistent across cloud vendors.

The Openshift container platform also packages some useful open-source add-ons with corporate support, for example:

Red Hat’s strategy is to pick the most renowned open-source project in each domain and add enterprise support to it. However, for management portal, Red Hat developed its own Advanced Cluster Management tool for Kubernetes, and open-sourced it in 2020 in the upstream project Open Cluster Management.

Similar to OpenShift, VMware Tanzu also attempts to cover the domains, with a smaller product portfolio:

Service Mesh: compatible with Istio
Mission Control: management portal
Observability

Google Anthos is also a container platform. Their product line include, but not limited to:

Anthos Config Management (ACM)
Anthos Service Mesh (ASM, an Istio distribution)

SUSE, the developer of RKE, RKE2, and K3s) offers Rancher as multi-cluster management platform. Apart from the engines, SUSE also offers Lonhorn as a storage solution. However, they do not have offerings for service mesh or GitOps. So there is no doubt that Red Hat OpenShift has the most complete portfolio for Kubernetes.

There are also companies that only offers management platforms without their own Kubernetes distribution. For example:

Product capabilities in this category vary a lot and you should refer to their specific documentation to understand. You will probably see a stack chart from each of the platform provider (e.g. SUSE Enterprise Container, OpenShift, Tanzu, Anthos, Rafay) with all technology integrations.

Cluster Installation Tools

As we saw in the installation steps for OpenShift, they are highly dependent on platform. With public cloud, the provisioning process also applies only to a specific platform. Since Kubernetes Installation process is tedious, some tools emerged to help, for example: kubespray, kubeadm, kops and Cluster API. These are governed by SIG cluster lifecycle special interest group.

Here are some traditional options to install a Kubernetes clusters:

kube-up: the first tool to build cluster from 2015. It has been deprecated.
Kubeadm: a tool built to provide best-practice “fast paths” for creating Kubernetes clusters that are minimum viable, and secure. Kubeadm’s scope is limited to the local node filesystem and the Kubernetes API, and it is intended to be a composable building block of higher level tools. It is first released in Sep 2016. The high level configuration steps goes through initialization (kubeadm init), control plane (kubeadm join control plane), and node (kubeadm join node). Kubeadm does not integrate with cloud providers and it does not install addons (auth, monitoring, CNI, storage class)
Kubespray: runs on bare metal or VMs using Ansible for provisioning and orchestration. The first release was in Oct 2015. Since v2.3 (Oct 2017) kubespray started to use kubeadm internally. In addition to kubeadm, kubespray configures CNI, storage class, other CRI. It supports cloud providers and air-gap environment. However it does not support infrastructure management.

The options above are official options. You may use kubeadm and kubespray to quickly (i.e. in an hour) spin up clusters for education purposes. However, with their limitations, it typically requires a lot of efforts to build a production-grade cluster with the needed addons and integrations.

Apart from the official options, there are also unofficial tools such as kubicorn, which was first introduced in 2018 as a cluster management framework with modular support for cloud providers. However it appears to be short-lived.

In the next two sections, we introduce kops and cluster API, two most recent projects to install cluster.

Kops

The kops utility directly perform the provisioning and orchestration via API to the cloud deployment engine. Kops, with first release in Oct 2016, is tightly integrated with the unique features of the cloud providers (e.g. AWS: ASG, ELB, EBS, KMS, S3, IAM). However, kops is only CLI without controller-style reconciliation. It does not support baremetal or vsphere. It also bundles addons with fixed version.

When picking a tool to install cluster, we need to strike a balance between how much simplification the tool brings, and how many different platform the installer can work with. Kops appears to be such a good compromise. It works with a number of cloud platforms using different set of APIs, although most are in alpha and beta stages today. Here is how to install cluster on AWS.

Both kops and Cluster API have good momentum but they work differently. Cluster API was first released in Mar 2019, and is currently less mature than kops. However, it is declarative and may reflect the direction of where cluster lifecycle management is heading.

Cluster API

Cluster API focuses on following areas:

Manage cluster lifecycle declaratively
Infrastructure abstraction (e.g. computing, storage, networking, security, etc)
Utilizing existing tools (e.g. kubeadm, cloud-init)
Modular and pluggable: to be adaptable to different infrastructure providers.

It involves a number of CRs as illustrated in its diagram. We should be clear on the providers for Bootstrap, Infrastructure and Control Plane.

The biggest benefit is the controller pattern to manage the entire lifecycle of a cluster. This allows managing clusters with GitOps, and rolling upgrade of the cluster. It also allows for declarative node scaling, self healing and multi-cluster management.

The client utility for is clusterctl, and with that along with the manifest, we can create a cluster in a few commands. A lot of workflows are still in development but we can take a look at its quick start guide to get a taste of how it works. The installation steps vary a lot based on the environment and the cluster. Also it introduces the separation of management cluster and workload cluster.

Workload cluster is the target cluster being created, as per the manifests.
Management cluster is where you keep track of the workload cluster being managed. You can manage multiple workload clusters from a single management cluster. Note that this management cluster will store credentials about workload clusters, and may become a single point of failure.

Although Cluster API reflects a great initiative to standardize the provisioning of Kubernetes cluster, whether it will succeed has to do with the level of complexity. In the next section, we will get a taste of how it looks to deploy a Kubernetes cluster in a lab.

Management cluster vs workload cluster

In the lab, I use my MacBook to create a management cluster with KinD. Then we configure a workload cluster in AWS from the management cluster.

Cluster API Lab

Note that the steps here are based on the quick start guide on Cluster API document. Also, there is a bug with the AWS provider so the end of the lab will report a warning. The main purpose of this lab is to demonstrate how Cluster API is supposed to work, even though it still has yet to mature.

To start, I install clusterctl (the cluster API client utility), clusterawsadm (the utility specific for AWS) on MacBook, then start a simple KinD cluster.

curl -L https://github.com/kubernetes-sigs/cluster-api/releases/download/v1.2.0/clusterctl-darwin-amd64 -o clusterctl
chmod +x ./clusterctl
sudo mv ./clusterctl /usr/local/bin/clusterctl
clusterctl version

curl -L https://github.com/kubernetes-sigs/cluster-api-provider-aws/releases/download/v1.4.1/clusterawsadm-darwin-amd64 -o clusterawsadm
chmod +x clusterawsadm
sudo mv clusterawsadm /usr/local/bin
clusterawsadm version

kind create cluster

So far, I installed the required utility and a KinD cluster on MacBook. Then I use clusterawsadm to create InstanceProfile, ManagedPolicy and IAM Roles required for cluster creation. The AWS region and access are configured as environment variables:

export AWS_REGION=us-east-1
export AWS_ACCESS_KEY_ID=AKIAXXXXXXXXXXX
export AWS_SECRET_ACCESS_KEY=J8ByduiofpwuisDjDoijOISDs
clusterawsadm bootstrap iam create-cloudformation-stack

This runs a CloudFormation stack to create the permission related resources:

Then I initialize the management cluster with the clusterctl utility, specifying AWS as a provider. I also need to assign the environment variable AWS_B64ENCODED_CREDENTIALS with proper value:

export AWS_B64ENCODED_CREDENTIALS=$(clusterawsadm bootstrap credentials encode-as-profile)
clusterctl init --infrastructure aws

Now I use clusterctl to generate the manifest for the workload cluster. In environment variables, I specify cluster and node sizes, SSH key name, control plane machine type and node machine type:

export AWS_SSH_KEY_NAME=cskey
export AWS_CONTROL_PLANE_MACHINE_TYPE=t3.large
export AWS_NODE_MACHINE_TYPE=t3.large
clusterctl generate cluster myekscluster --kubernetes-version 1.24.3 --control-plane-machine-count=3 --worker-machine-count=3 > capi-quickstart.yaml

kubectl apply -f capi-quickstart.yaml

At the end I tell the management cluster to create a workload cluster as per the manifest, by simply declaring the CRs. It will take some time for the cluster to create, and there are a number of ways to monitor the progress. You can monitor the log on the controller pods in their respect namespaces. You can also check the cluster status with:

kubectl get kubeadmcontrolplane
clusterctl describe cluster myekscluster

Currently there is a bug and the commands at the end will report as below:

Hopefully the bug will be fixed shortly. To delete the cluster, simply delete the resources in the manifest with kubectl delete -f capi-quickstart.yaml

Summary

There are numerous ways to build a Kubernetes cluster. Before deciding on the approach, I recommend having a full understanding of the hosting environment. This is because installation approach and hosting environment are still tightly coupled. This is the status quo and is not going to change in the near future. Both kops and cluster API reflects initiative to decouple the two but both are still in early stage and already facing growing complexity. Cluster API manages complexity with CRDs to abstract system resources and infrastructure, as illustrated here:

CRDs and providers to abstract system resources and infrastructure

The diagram is from the “Cluster API and declarative Kubernetes Management” white paper. Here is a stream with more about the same topic.

Etcd – the key-value store for Kubernetes

Tue, 14 Jun 2022 00:10:00 -0400

Etcd in Kubernetes

In Kubernetes architecture, etcd is the data store. It stores the desired state of Kubernetes object. API server is the only client that connects to etcd (via gRPC protocol). Cluster builder specifies the endpoint of etcd as a parameter to the kube-api-server process. Other Kubernetes components, whether in the control plane or from the nodes, connect to API server. API server translates their request into etcd query, and then translates etcd query result into what its clients ask for. For this reason, communication with etcd accounts for a lot of network traffic in a Kubernetes cluster.

The etcd store is a CNCF project for “a distributed, reliable key-value store for critical data in a distributed system”, developed by CoreOS team. So it is essentially a distributed key-value store for any distributed application. If an application runs on Kubernetes, it can leverage etcd store, by keeping their configurations in ConfigMap and Secret objects. One key feature is to watch for specific keys or directories for changes, and react to the changes. Voila! This is the underlying mechanism for controller!

A Kubernetes cluster may have stacked etcd deployment or connect to an external etcd store.

stacked etcd architecture

external etcd architecture

In managed Kubernetes services such as EKS in AWS and AKS in Azure, users usually do not directly access etcd store. However, it is still a very important component to understand. Its use case includes:

Configuration sharing
Service discovery
Consistency
Watching mechanism
Expiry and extension of key

The consistency use case is based on Raft protocol for distributed consensus.

Raft protocol

I am not an expert in distributed consensus protocols and nor do I intent to cover it in depth. At a high level, I have heard of three of them so far:

Etcd uses Raft protocol
Zookeeper uses ZAB protocol
Cassandra uses paxos protocol

Here is a good intro to the three protocols. Instead of getting into the fine details, I would like to discuss why we need such a consensus protocol (or consensus mechanism) in distributed systems, which are also decentralized systems.

Centralized, Decentralized, Distributed systems

The reason a distributed system needs consensus protocol, is that a distributed system lacks a single source of truth as centralized systems do. Different parts of the distributed system may receive different signals but they must come to agreement of a single plan to act. Lamport studies this with an analogy of Byzantine Generals problem, and first proposed Paxos protocol. Paxos has been an important foundation to modern distributed systems. In Paxos, consensus is achieved in two phases, which creates the problem of livelocks. Raft is an alternative to Paxos, and is widely adopted today. Here is a link to an animated illustration for Raft protocol. The Raft protocol is also used in Redis. It has three roles: Leader, Candidate, and follower. ZAB protocol is similar to Raft, where it needs to select a leader.

Etcd Lab

In troubleshooting, if we suspect that the response from API server is inconsistent with etcd store, we want to directly connect to it.

Managed Kubernetes services do not expose their etcd store. We can use KinD or Minikube. There are two types of jump box to access etcd store: using etcd Pod, or SSH to a Node. To connect to etcd, we also need the X509 key, certificate and CA’s certificate, in addition to the endpoint, usually an IP with port 2389. When I connect to Pod shell, I find the command shell not easy to use. They might miss basic command such as ls, or do not support auto completion.

Take KinD for example, we first create a secret, then we can connect to the node with docker CLI command:

kubectl create ns myns
kubectl -n myns create secret generic mysecret --from-literal key1=value1
kubectl -n myns get secret mysecret -o jsonpath='{.data.key1}' | base64 -d
docker exec -it control /bin/bash

From the node,

apt update && apt install etcd-client
etcdctl version
nc -vz localhost 2379
cat /etc/kubernetes/manifests/kube-apiserver.yaml | grep etcd

export ETCDCTL_API=3
export ETCDCTL_CERT=/etc/kubernetes/pki/apiserver-etcd-client.crt
export ETCDCTL_KEY=/etc/kubernetes/pki/apiserver-etcd-client.key
export ETCDCTL_CACERT=/etc/kubernetes/pki/etcd/ca.crt
export ETCDCTL_ENDPOINTS='https://127.0.0.1:2379'
etcdctl member list write out=table

Now we can see the secret object directly with etcd store:

etcdctl get /registry/secrets/myns/mysecret

With get query, when using –prefix, we can use –keys-only switch to list keys without values:

etcdctl get --prefix /registry/api --keys-only
etcdctl get --prefix /registry/namespace -wjson

We can write key-value with put command:

etcdctl put myloc 0
etcdctl get myloc -wjson

In Kubernetes, all the key names start with / which makes the key looks like a POSIX path. Every Kubernetes object is stored in etcd with a unique key following a self-explanatory naming pattern. To display the path, we can also use debug log that records the call to API server:

kubectl get ns myns -v9

Look for curl command such as:

I0523 22:51:43.517728 32347 round_trippers.go:466] curl -v -XGET -H "Accept: application/json;as=Table;v=v1;g=meta.k8s.io,application/json;as=Table;v=v1beta1;g=meta.k8s.io,application/json" -H "User-Agent: kubectl/v1.23.6 (darwin/amd64) kubernetes/ad33385" 'https://127.0.0.1:64081/api/v1/namespaces/myns'

From there we can see the etcd query as the URI is namespaces/myns, which we use in etcdctl query path:

etcdctl get /registry/namespaces/myns

Every type of Kubernetes object has a storage.go file in their implementation that defines how api server should write object. Here is an example for Pod object.

Etcd also supports watch command to watch for changes. For example:

etcdctl watch --prefix /registry/namespace # watch output k create ns newns

Now we create a namespace with kubectl:

kubectl create ns myns

The output from etcdctl will reflect the change. The communication between etcdctl and etcd is gRPC protocol. The output is based on stream, as we can see from the watch result.

Etcd Maintenance

Like any distributed store, etcd needs maintenance and operation work. For example, we can check endpoint status with endpoint command:

etcdctl endpoint status

We can also backup and restore etcd store with etcdctl command:

etcdctl snapshot save /tmp/backup.db

This was an question in CKA exam. In real life, when the workload scales up, the etcd store may come across many pitfalls, such as degraded performance, unresponsiveness, some etcd member going down, network partition on etcd store causing split brain. It is important to ensure efficient communication between API server and etcd store. The etcdctl provides defrag and compact commands for common maintenance activities.

Certified Kubernetes Administrator (CKA) Exam

Fri, 30 Apr 2021 09:50:00 -0400

The Certified Kubernetes Administrator (CKA) exam is a hands-on session where you need to follow the instructions to configure the system in a bash terminal on the web browser. In my experience, some shortcut keys (such as Alt+F) do not work, which slows me down a little bit. For each question, you need to switch kubectl context as instructed in the question. Some questions share the same context so it is very easy to omit this step. You can verify response with your own command but will not be told whether you scored in each question. During the CKA exam I tried to spin up a terminal session from within Vim editor and the terminal ran out of buffer. I had to reboot the machine with the help of proctor, and my completed work are saved.

In general this is an exam I enjoy preparing and writing because it is very hands on. Result is out a day after, and I passed at 96%. I heard about tight timelines but I managed to finish 15 minutes before the end, most likely owing to my dexterity with Linux commands. With that I’m happy to share my notes in preparation for the CKA exam.

For taking CKA exam, we should be familiar with the diagram above.

Tips for Troubleshooting

The CKA exam is hands-on and therefore requires quite a bit of troubleshooting. Here are my notes.

Check Node status to start with
Check core services on each node:
- sudo systemctl status kubelet
- sudo systemctl status docker
- sudo journalctl -u kubelet
- sudo journalctl -u docker
Check component logs (on hosting VM)
- /var/log/kube-apiserver.log
- /var/log/kube-scheduler.log
- /var/log/kube-controller-manager.log
If cluster is built by kubeadm, then some of those services are running in Pods within kube-system namespace. Check those pods:
- run interactive shell: > kubectl exec podname –stdin –tty — /bin/sh
- there is an image for lots of useful network tool called nicolaka/netshoot

Store pod names to variable. e.g. > POD_NAME=$(kubectl get pods -l run=nginx -o jsonpath=”{.items[0].metadata.name}”)
With kubectl, you may
- alias it to k for faster typing
- –dry-run: to run imperative command without creating object
- –record: record the command that was used to make a change
- -o: set output format, wide, yaml, or jsonpath=”expression”. For example, to get pod name: > kubectl get pods -l run=nginx -o jsonpath=”{.items[0].metadata.name}”
- –sort-by: use JSONPath expression
- –selector: filter results by label

Build K8s cluster using kubeadm

The CKA exam requires you to know how to build cluster with kubeadm. This involves installing four components (docker-ce, kubeadm, kubectl and kubelet), as outlined below:

step	command
1. Install docker-ce	> curl -fsSL https://download.docker.com/linux/ubuntu/gpg \| sudo apt-key add - > sudo add-apt-repository \ "deb [arch=amd64] https://download.docker.com/linux/ubuntu \ $(lsb_release -cs) \ stable" > sudo apt-get update > sudo apt-get install -y docker-ce=18.06.1~ce~3-0~ubuntu > sudo apt-mark hold docker-ce > sudo systemctl status docker
2. Install kubeadm, kubelet and kubectl	> curl -s https://packages.cloud.google.com/apt/doc/apt-key.gpg \| sudo apt-key add - cat << EOF \| sudo tee /etc/apt/sources.list.d/kubernetes.list deb https://apt.kubernetes.io/ kubernetes-xenial main EOF > sudo apt-get update > sudo apt-get install -y kubelet kubeadm kubectl > sudo apt-mark hold kubelet kubeadm kubectl
3. Form a K8s cluster	On master node: > sudo kubeadm init --pod-network-cidr=10.244.0.0/16 This command prints out a command for worker nodes to join.	On worker node: sudo the command generated on master
4. Configure kubectl	On master node: > mkdir -p $HOME/.kube > sudo cp -i /etc/kubernetes/admin.conf $HOME/.kube/config > sudo chown $(id -u):$(id -g) $HOME/.kube/config	Optionally on worker node: > mkdir -p $HOME/.kube then scp $HOME/.kube/config from control plane node
5. Set up cluster networking	> echo "net.bridge.bridge-nf-call-iptables=1" \| sudo tee -a /etc/sysctl.conf > sudo sysctl -p Then from any environment with kubectl, bring up the system pods for cluster networking > kubectl apply -f https://raw.githubusercontent.com/coreos/flannel/master/Documentation/kube-flannel.yml

Add new node to KubeAdm cluster

This is fairly simple with the help of kubeadm. The node to join cluster must be able to communicate with master node. Create a token and print join command from master node:

> kubeadm token create --print-join-command

Then from the node to join, run this command as sudo. You will see that it performs the TLS bootstrap for you. Once completed, the standard output will say this node has joined the cluster. You can confirm with command:

> kubectl get nodes

Sometimes one needs to migrate pods to the newly joined node. This can be done by draining the existing nodes.

Note you can also use kubespray to build K8s cluster as previously discussed, and here is a my IaC project to launch AWS instances and build a K8s cluster with kubespray on top of it. For my learning, I often create a GKE (Google Kubernetes Engine) cluster from GCP’s cloudshell. There is a guide on how to start a cluster but it comes down to three commands:

$ gcloud config set compute/zone us-east1-b
$ gcloud container clusters create tcluster --num-nodes=3
$ gcloud container clusters get-credentials tcluster

The third command above is to configure kubectl on the cloudshell. Follow this guide if you need to SSH to node.

Upgrade KubeAdm cluster

This involves upgrade three components (kubeadm, kubectl and kubelet) on two types of node: master node and worker node. They steps vary slightly for two nodes. But drain and uncordon is needed for both types of nodes. Pick a node and follow the steps below:

Step	Command
1. drain the node from kubectl client (e.g. master node)	> sudo kubectl drain nodename --ignore-daemonsets
2. Determine kubeadm target version	> apt-mark showhold > sudo apt-mark unhold kubeadm kubectl kubelet > apt list --installed \| grep kube > apt-cache show kubeadm \| less > sudo apt-get install -y kubeadm=1.20.2-00
3. update kubeadm	On master node: > sudo kubeadm upgrade plan v1.20.2 > sudo kubeadm upgrade apply v1.20.2	On worker node: > sudo kubeadm upgrade node
4. On the node to update, determine target version for kubectl and kubelet, then install	> apt-cache show kubectl \| less > apt-cache show kubelet \| less > sudo apt-get install -y kubectl=1.20.2-00 kubelet=1.20.2-00
5. Restart kubelet	> sudo systemctl daemon-reload > sudo systemctl restart kubelet
6. Uncordon	> kubectl uncordon nodename

Backup and restore Etcd

Etcd is a distributed key-value store. It uses Raft protocol for distributed consensus. Etcd is the third distributed system I touch on. The previous two are: Cassandra (using Paxos protocol for distributed consensus) and ZooKeeper (using ZAB protocol). Here is a good article that summarizes the protocols. As for the exam we only need to use etcd with the client tool.

The etcd itself can run on a cluster of servers, each running etcd as a systemd service as etcd/etcd (user/group). It can be deployed in two ways:

stacked etcd: an instance of etcd lives with kube-api-server on the same control plane node
external etcd: in a dedicated cluster of etcd

Alternatively, etcd can run as a pod, most likely in kube-system namespace.

The etcd service listens on port 2379 for client communication and on port 2380 for server (peer-to-peer) communication. When the systemd service was initialized there are a few key environment variables (e.g. cert locations, ETCD_DATA_DIR) privoded as configuration. To see them, run:

> cat /etc/systemd/system/etcd.service | grep Env

These environment variables (prefixed with ETCD_) are for the service only. They can provide current configuration information for us to use later. When it’s running as a pod, check out the directory for static pod for the yaml declaration (e.g. /etc/Kubernetes/manifests/etcd.yaml), where these parameters are passed in as environment variable.

The etcdctl utility is a command line client for etcd. The default API version is 3 so no need any more to set ETCDCTL_API=3 before each command. The utility needs three arguments three arguments (–cacert, –cert, and –key) but we can pass the information via environment variables:

> export ETCDCTL_CACERT= /home/cloud_user/etcd-certs/etcd-ca.pem
> export ETCDCTL_CERT= /home/cloud_user/etcd-certs/etcd-server.crt
> export ETCDCTL_KEY= /home/cloud_user/etcd-certs/etcd-server.key
> export ETCDCTL_ENDPOINTS=https://etcd1:2379

The environment variable names are uppercase of the argument name with prefix ETCDCTL_. Only global options of arguments can be supplied via environment variables. They remain effective throughout the rest of activities. Also note that the CACERT is needed only when client-cert-auth is true. Now to backup, we can simply run:

> etcdctl snapshot save /home/cloud_user/etcd_backup.db

To restore from a file, you want to remove existing etcd data directory first. The directory can be found in ETCD_DATA_DIR variable. Suppose it is /var/lib/etcd, you need root permission to write to it, then correct ownership before starting the service:

> sudo systemctl stop etcd && sudo mv /var/lib/etcd/ /tmp/
> sudo etcdctl snapshot restore /home/cloud_user/etcd_backup.db --data-dir /var/lib/etcd
> sudo chown -R etcd:etcd /var/lib/etcd && sudo systemctl start etcd

To verify the restore result, simply run:

> etcdctl get cluster.name

Object Management

In the CKA exam, we need to interact with many types of built-in Kubernetes objects.

RBAC objects:
- A Role defines permissions within namespace.
- A ClusterRole defines cluster-wide permissions.
- Both Roles and ClusterRoles are K8s objects that defines a set of permissions
- RoleBinding and ClusterRoleBinding are objects that connect Roles and ClusterRoles to users.
Service Account: an account used by container processes within Pods to authenticate the K8s API. If your Pods need to communicate with the K8s API, you can use service accounts to control their access.

Inspect resource usage either with a K8s Metrics Server, or by command:

> kubectl top pod --sort-by <JSONPATH> --selector <selector>

Here is a good guide to install metrics server and dashboard (e.g. on docker-desktop).

Pods and Containers

ConfigMaps: store data in key-value map.
Secrets: same as ConfigMaps but for sensitive data only
Two ways to pass ConfigMap and Secret data to your container:
- As environment variables in container operating system
- As files presented on mounted volumes in container file system.
Container Resource management:
- Resource requests: K8s scheduler will use resource requests to avoid scheduling pods on nodes that do not have enough available resources. 1 CPU unit = 1/1000 of one core
- Resource limits: allow you to limit the amount of resources your containers can use. The container runtime is responsible for enforcement. The enforcement behaviour is different. For example, some terminates container that attempts to use more resource than the limit.
Probes
- Liveness Probe: automatically determine whether or not a container application is in a healthy state. By default K8s does not consider a container to be down until the container process stops. Liveness Probe allow you to customize this detection mechanism and make it more sophisticated.
- Startup Probes: similar to liveness probes. However, while liveness probes run constantly on a schedule, startup probes run at container startup and stop running once they succeed. Startup probes are used to determine when the application has successfully started up. It is especially useful for legacy applications that can have long startup times.
- Readiness Probes: determine when a container is ready to accept requests. When you have a service backed by multiple container endpoints, user traffic will not be sent to a particular pod until its containers have all passed the readiness checks defined by their readinesse probes. Use readiness probes to prevent user traffic from being sent to pods that are still in the process of starting up.

Restart policy for self-healing pods
- (default) Always: container will always be restarted if they stop, even if they completed successfully (returned 0).
- OnFailure: container will be restarted if the container process exists with an error code, or the container is determined to be unhealthy by a liveness probe.
- Never: let it be
Multi-container pods:
- containers share the same networking namespace and can communicate with one another on any port, even if the port is not exposed to the cluster
- Container can use volumes to share data in a Pod. Example: a legacy application is hard-coded to write log output to a file on disk. You use a sidecar container to read the log file from shared volume and prints it to the console so the log output will appear in the container log.
Init containers: containers that run once during the startup process of a pod. A pod can have any number of init containers, and they will each run once into completion, before the next init container starts. You may use init containers to perform a variety of startup tasks, they can contain and use software and setup scripts that are not needed by your main containers. They are often useful in keeping your main containers lighter and more secure by offloading startup tasks to a separate container. Use case include:
- cause a pod to wait for another K8s resource to be created before finishing startup
- perform sensitive startup steps securely outside of app containers
- populate data into a shared volume at startup
- communicate with another service at startup
Scheduling: Scheduler (a component in control plane) assigns Pods to a suitable Node so kubelets can run them. The factor taken into account:
- resource request vs available node resources
- various configurations that affect scheduling using node labels
Pod allocation
- nodeSelector is an attribute of Pod to allow you to limit which Node(s) the Pod can be scheduled on. The selector is based on label.
- nodeName is an attribute of Pod that allows you to bypass scheduling and assign Pod to a specific Node by name.
DaemonSet: automatically runs a copy of a Pod on each node. When a new node is added to the clsuter, DaemonSet will run a new copy of the Pod on it. DaemonSets also respect normal scheduling rules around node labels, taints and tolerations. If a pod would not normally be scheduled on a node, a DaemonSet will not create a copy of the Pod on that node.
Static Pod: A Pod that is managed directly by the kubelet on a node, not by the K8s API server. They can run even if there is not K8s API server present. Kubelet automatically creates static Pods from YAML manifest files located in the manifest path on the node.
Mirror Pod: Kubelet will create a mirror Pod for each static Pod. Mirror Pods allow you to see the status of the static Pod via the K8s API, but you cannot change or manage them via the API.
Taints: applied to nodes to repel a set of pods. A taint specifies key-value and effect. Effect can be NoSchedule or NoEffect. The former prevents pods without matching tolerations to schedule to the tainted node. The latter also evicts pre-existing pods with no matching toleration.
Tolerations: applied to pods so they can be scheduled to nodes with matching taints. A toleration consists of key-value pair, effect and operation. The operation can be Equal or Exists. To determine whether a toleration matches a taint. The keys and the effects must be the same. In addition:
- the operator is Exists (and thus no value should be specified in the toleration); or
- the operator is Equal, and all the values match those of the taints;

Now we have three ways to influence the scheduling behaviour. The first, is simply by specifying nodeSelector on the Pod, with the required the node label. The second, as just discussed, is to use Taints and Tolerations. The third way, is similar to the first, using nodeAffinity attributes on Pods. nodeAffinity is more powerful and flexible than nodeSelector by supporting more complex scheduling rules (e.g. matching rules).

Use Node Affinity when your scheduling rule is based on direct condition, i.e. schedule a Pod to this Node when XXX. In this case, you have well-known labels on nodes, and specify nodeAffinity on Pods.
Use Taints and Tolerations when your scheduling rule is based on inverse statement, i.e. do not schedule a Pod to this Node unless XXX. In this case, you put a taint “MyCondition:NoSchedule” on a Node, so that no Pod will ever get scheduled to this Node. The only exception is when a Pod has the Toleration “MyCondition:NoSchedule”.

Deployments

Deployment is an object that defines a desired state for a ReplicaSet (a set of replica Pods). The Deployment Controller seeks to maintain the desired state by creating, deleting, and replacing Pods with new configurations.
With Deployments, you can horizontally scale an application up and down by changing the number of replicas. You can perform rolling updates and rollback.

Networking

The K8s network model defines how Pods communicate with each other, regardless of which Node they are running on.
Each Pod has its own unique IP address within the cluster. Any Pod can reach any other Pod using that Pod’s IP address. This creates a virtual network that allows Pods to easily communicate with each other.
One type of K8s network plugin is CNI plugin. It has many flavours such as Calico. Each plugin has its own unique installation process. Kubenetes nodes will remain NotReady until a network plugin is installed.
The K8s virtual network uses a DNS (e.g. a Kubeadm cluster uses CoreDNS pod in kube-system namespace) to allow Pods to locate other Pods and Services using domain names. The Pod DNS name follows this format: pod-ip-address.namespace.pod.cluster.local
A K8s NetworkPolicy is an object that allows you to control the flow of network communication to and from Pods so you can isolate traffic. NetworkPolicy can apply to Ingress (using from selector), Egress (using to selector) or both.
NetworkPolicy has an attribute podSelector to determine to which Pods in the namespace the NetworkPolicy applies, by selecting Pods by with Pod labels.
By default, Pods are considered non-isolated and completed open to all communication. If any NetworkPolidy selects a Pod, the Pod is considered isolated and will only be open to traffic allowed by NetworkPolicies.
A variety of selector can be used: podSelector, namespaceSelector, ipBlockSelector and port.

Services

Services provide a way to expose an application running as a set of pods, so clients can access applications in an abstract way without needing to be aware of the application pods. In this model, client make requests to a Service, which routes traffic to its pods in a load-balanced fashion
Endpoints are the backend entities to which Services route traffic. If there are multiple Pods behind a service, each Pod will have an endpoint associated with the service.
Each service has a type that determines how and where service will expose your application.
- ClusterIP: expose application inside the cluster network
- NodePort: expose application outside the cluster network
- LoadBalancer: expose application outside thecluster network, but use an extermal cloud load balancer from cloud platform.
Services are assigned with DNS names. The FQDN follows this format: service.namespace.svc.cluster-domain.example, which is used by pods across namespaces
Pods within the same namespace can reference service simply by service name.
To manage external access to service, you can also use Ingress object. Ingress object is capable of providing more functionality than a simple NodePort Service, such as SSL termination, advanced load balancing, or name-based virtual hosting. You must install one or more Ingerss controller (many different implementations) to back up the ingress objects.
Ingress defines a set of routing rules. Each rule has a set of paths, each with a backend. Requests matching a path will be routed to its associated backend.
If a Service uses a named port, an ingress can also use the port’s name (instead of port number) to choose to which port of a service it will route.

Storage

Volumes allow you to store data outside the container file system, while allowing the container to access the data at runtime. When Pod is gone, volumes do not persist.
Persistent Volumes are a slightly more advanced form of Volume. They allow you to treat storage as an abstract resource and consume it in Pods. PV can be provisioned separately by storage administrator, and they persist regardless of pod lifecycle. PV needs to be claimed by pods. PV uses a set of attributes to describe the underlying storage resource.
Both volumes and PVs each have a volume type: NFS, Cloud (AWS, Azure, GCP), ConfigMaps and Secrets, Simple Directory on node
Two volume types to distinguish:
- hostPath: store data in a specified directory on K8s node
- emptyDir: store data in dynamically created location on the node. The directory exists only as long as the Pod exists on the node. The directory and the data are deleted as Pod is removed. This type is useful for simply sharing data between containers in the same pod.
Both volumes and PVs are specified under Pod, and individual containers must include volumeMounts object to map volume name to local mountPath
Storage Class object allow K8s admins to specify the types of storage services they offer on their platform. A key property is allowVolumeExpansion. This allows PVC to resize. At storage class level, there are two reclaim policies: Retain and Delete. The default is Delete.
PV has an attribute named persistentVolumeReclaimPolicy. This is reclaim policy at PV level. If the attribute is not defined, it is inherited from storage class. The persistentVolumeReclaimPolicy has three options. When PVC is deleted:
- Retain: keeps all data but requires admin to manually reclaim the volume (i.e. delete PV, clean up data, delete storage asset)
- Delete (cloud storage only): deletes both PV and the underlying storage resource automatically
- Recycle: scrub (rm -rf /vol/) all data in the underlying storage resource, and allow the volume to be reused.
PVC represents a user’s request for storage resources. It defines a set of attributes similiar to those of a PV. When a PVC is created, it will look for a PV that is able to meet the requested criteria. If it finds one, it will automatically be bound to the PV. PVC can be mounted to a Pod’s containers just like any other volume

In general the CKA exam experience is quite positive and rewarding. In future posts I will shift focus on Kubernetes not only for the CKA exam, but also for keeping track of my learning.

Good luck with your CKA exam.